Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan will speak with reporters before Tuesday’s practice. The headline topic will be the team’s decision to sign Jimmy Garoppolo to a restructured one-year deal, keeping the quarterback on the roster while significantly reducing his salary-cap figure.
The 49ers now own about $21 million in salary-cap space, per Over The Cap. That’s up from about $3 million as of Monday morning. The deal has reportedly been in the works since last week but wasn’t revealed until NFL insider Adam Schefter spilled all the glorious details.
San Francisco sought to trade Garoppolo all offseason. That failed miserably. The 49ers aren’t entirely to blame, though. The quarterback shocked the team with his decision to undergo shoulder surgery on March 8. That threw a wrench into Lynch and Shanahan’s plan.
Soon after, the once-booming market of quarterback-needy teams evaporated. The Niners had moved forward with second-year quarterback Trey Lance, last year’s No. 3 overall pick, as their starter. Regardless of where things stood with their former starter, the Garoppolo-49ers marriage appeared set for a divorce.
Along the way, the 49ers did what you expected. They touted their faith in the 22-year-old quarterback while giving every indication that the 30-year-old quarterback’s time in the Bay Area was over.
Now, Garoppolo is staying, and he will serve as his once-protégé’s backup. Understandably, the news sent social media into a frenzy.
While most see this as a business decision, perhaps the only move available for a team that lacked options, San Francisco could have released Garoppolo. That would have freed up even more salary-cap space, but that might have resulted in Garoppolo signing with the Seattle Seahawks and facing his former team twice this season. That probably wasn’t ideal in Lynch’s and Shanahan’s eyes.
One Bay Area reporter views the situation differently, though. He sees San Francisco’s decision to keep Garoppolo as a statement about the team’s feelings about the inexperienced Lance.
“This is a hedge, plain and simple,” wrote Michael Silver of the San Francisco Chronicle. “And the reason the 49ers are hedging is because they’re worried that Lance, for all his promise, won’t be good enough to get their built-to-win-now team to its only acceptable destination — Glendale, Ariz., next February 12, with York hoisting the franchise’s sixth Lombardi Trophy.”
Silver points towards Lance’s inconsistent training camp and even the quarterback’s shaky outing during the preseason finale against the Houston Texans as reasons why doubt might have crept into Shanahan’s head.
“Most concerning, he had issues with accuracy and consistency,” Silver continued. “Sometimes during OTAs, he looked like a guy who could zip the ball from Point A to Point B with NFL-caliber proficiency. At other times, he looked like Ricky (Wild Thing) Vaughn in the first act of ‘Major League.’ … You’d better believe that Shanahan and his assistants were at least somewhat unnerved.”
Silver believes that, paired with a lack of viable Garoppolo options, landed the 49ers where they are now. If things do go south with Lance, either due to an injury or inconsistent play, the team likely believes Garoppolo isn’t a bad Plan B to have.
Click here to read Silver’s full column.
Report it.
Facebook Comments
More San Francisco 49ers News

Jerry Rice: “It’s time to move on” from Jimmy Garoppolo, allow 49ers’ Trey Lance to become a “superstar”
Years removed from playing in the NFL, Hall of Fame wide receiver Jerry Rice still closely follows the San Francisco 49ers, the team that made him the No. 16 overall draft pick in 1985. He has been keeping up with this offseason’s storylines and went on 95.7 The Game this week to discuss the quarterback situation. Second-year quarterback Trey Lance is headed into his first season as the full-time starter. The previous starter, Jimmy Garoppolo, appears to be in limbo—for now. Officially, he remains on the 49ers roster. However, he hasn’t practiced with the team or participated in meetings. Instead, Garoppolo has been working on the sidelines, preparing for the next chapter in his NFL journey. Garoppolo is healthy again, nearly six months after his March 8

Kyle Shanahan: Trey Lance won’t “make or break” 49ers’ 2022 season
The San Francisco 49ers probably would have done well last season with or without Jimmy Garoppolo at the helm for the majority of the games. They may not have been a lock for an NFC Championship Game appearance without their steady game manager, but the season probably wouldn’t have been a flop with rookie Trey Lance under center. The reason for that is the level of talent on the roster. The team was loaded with playmakers on both sides of the football. A case could be made that Lance should have played more. The then-21-year-old quarterback, more than anything, needed reps—more than the two starts he got filling in for an injured Garoppolo. He entered the NFL with just 17 collegiate starts under his belt and only 318 passes

ESPN’s Chris Canty predicts Trey Lance and 49ers in Super Bowl
ESPN’s Chris Canty, a former NFL defensive end, doesn’t believe it will take long for San Francisco 49ers quarterback Trey Lance to prove himself in the NFL. Canty is expecting an MVP-caliber season from the second-year player, and that’s not all. “I know you guys left me out of the bold prediction, but my bold prediction for this season is that the 49ers represent the NFC in the Super Bowl,” Canty said on ESPN’s GetUp. “That’s how confident I am in this 49ers team and the development of Trey Lance, because of who’s doing it—Kyle Shanahan—and what’s around him—the supporting cast. “You’re talking about a top-five run game, a top -five skill-position core, and a top-five defense. All the elements are there for Trey Lance to be successful,

GMFB explains why 49ers’ Trey Lance could take off in 2022
What will the San Francisco 49ers offense be like in 2022? Will it be better or worse than the version helmed by quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo? That was the question asked on Good Morning Football this week. Garoppolo’s time with the Niners has come to an end. While the veteran remains on the roster, the offense now belongs to Garoppolo’s successor, second-year quarterback Trey Lance. Kyle Brandt doesn’t believe the offense will be better in 2022 than the version that reached the NFC Championship Game last season, noting Lance’s inexperience as a primary reason why. “He’s just still so raw and so inexperienced,” Brandt said. “And I also think Jimmy Garoppolo is really good, and he’s gone. And I don’t think they’ll be better than last year. I
.